Join 40,000 other subscribers who get Great Leadership delivered directly to their inbox each week. You’ll get access to my best thinking and latest content. Sign up today.
…
If you’re a Chief Human Resources or Chief People Officer, then you can request to join a brand new community I put together called Future Of Work Leaders which focuses on the future of work and employee experience. Join leaders from Tractor Supply, Johnson & Johnson, Lego, Dow, Northrop Grumman and many others. We come together virtually each month and once a year in-person to tackle big themes that go beyond traditional HR.
High-stakes negotiations have become the norm in today’s business landscape, instilling constant pressure on leaders. How can leaders manage to close deals, manage stakeholder expectations, and secure buy-in for crucial initiatives all at once? James Sebenius, Harvard Professor and co-founder of Harvard’s Negotiation Program, has spent his career dissecting the very fabric of successful negotiations. He reveals that the best negotiators don’t rely on quick tactics alone. They use calculated strategies that set them up for success before the conversation even starts.
In this episode of Future Ready Leadership, James unveils some of the most powerful strategies that have been used by icons like Bob Iger, Jim Baker, and Henry Kissinger—strategies that every leader can leverage to achieve transformative results.
He explores the art of negotiation beyond the basics, introducing advanced tactics that can help leaders turn potential deadlocks into agreements and secure support from even the toughest stakeholders. This episode will give leaders the edge in every negotiation, from the critical importance of “setup” before a negotiation to the surprising value of empathy and “chess-like” thinking.
Listen to the episode here on Apple Podcast & leave a review!
The Most Overlooked Yet Powerful Aspects of Negotiation
When it comes to negotiation, too many leaders focus on tactics they plan to use in the room—the right words, the right expressions, the right data. But the real key to success is in what you do before the conversation even begins. Here are some of the most overlooked yet powerful aspects of negotiation that are often missed by even seasoned leaders:
-
The Setup Phase – Much of a successful negotiation happens long before both parties sit down at the table. This “setup” phase is the perfect time to align with stakeholders, identify key players, and sequence the negotiation steps in a way that maximizes leverage. The setup is where leaders can shape the terms of engagement, making it a game-changing move for any deal.
-
Using Intermediate Moves – James draws a parallel to chess, describing the concept of “intermediate moves” as strategic actions taken before the final play to position yourself advantageously. By managing the order and nature of each interaction, leaders can steer the negotiation path toward a more favorable outcome, often subtly directing the other party’s responses and choices without direct confrontation.
-
Balancing Empathy With Assertiveness – Great negotiators find a unique balance between empathy and assertiveness. James explains that understanding the perspectives and motivations of the other side doesn’t weaken your position; rather, it strengthens it by revealing ways to frame the negotiation in terms that resonate with both parties’ needs.
-
Sequencing – James also points out something that doesn’t get enough attention: the importance of sequencing. Imagine negotiating with a team of internal stakeholders before taking an offer to an external partner. James stresses that the order in which you approach these people can drastically impact your success. By strategically sequencing your conversations, you create a ripple effect that builds consensus in a way that’s far more powerful than a one-off discussion. It’s about taking a step back, thinking a few moves ahead, and ensuring every part of the negotiation works together to support your goal.
These are just a few of the tools James outlines, but they can fundamentally change the way you approach negotiation and help you build stronger relationships along the way.
Listen to the episode here on Apple Podcast & leave a review!
4 Ways to Enhance Your Negotiation Skills
Negotiation success depends on much more than just tactics. James reveals how leaders can use these principles to succeed in any negotiation, no matter how challenging:
-
Begin with Stakeholder Alignment: Before diving into the negotiation, take time to understand who needs to be involved and at what stage. It’s important to build support among key players early on, which allows for a more cohesive approach when it’s time to negotiate. For instance, if you’re pushing for a new project or initiative, getting buy-in from influential voices within the organization can often help smooth over potential resistance later on.
-
Think Like a Chess Player, Not a Checker: Negotiating isn’t about a simple back-and-forth. Leaders must think a few steps ahead, orchestrating moves that set up a stronger position before the critical moment arrives. This approach that James likens to chess, allows leaders to use intermediate moves—perhaps by introducing preliminary agreements or framing issues in stages—which gradually steer the negotiation in their favor without triggering opposition.
-
Use Empathy as a Tool, Not a Weakness: Many leaders underestimate the power of empathy in negotiation, often viewing it as a potential weakness. But James challenges this notion, noting that understanding the other side’s interests can actually provide leverage. By genuinely listening and addressing their needs, you can craft a proposal that feels like a win for both sides while still advancing your own objectives.
-
Focus on the Setup, Not Just the Tactics: Rather than relying solely on tactical maneuvers at the table, James advises leaders to spend more time preparing the negotiation environment. Setup involves identifying the right timing, understanding each party’s pressures and constraints, and anticipating objections. The way a negotiation is set up can often determine its outcome just as much, if not more, than the actual arguments presented.
Final Takeaway
Winning in negotiation isn’t about who talks the loudest or pushes the hardest—it’s about thoughtful preparation, strategic timing, and the ability to see the negotiation from all angles. By setting up the right environment, thinking strategically, and balancing empathy with assertiveness, leaders can transform their approach to securing high-stakes deals and building alignment.
If you’re serious about mastering the art of negotiation, don’t miss the full episode with James Sebenius, where he shares more strategies and stories that could make all the difference in your next big conversation.
Listen to the episode here on Apple Podcast & leave a review!
Comments